International Investment Agreements and their Impact on State Regulatory Space: The Case of Israel

Upcoming Events Login

Monday, March 25th, 2019

DateTimeLocation
Monday, March 25, 201912:00PM - 2:00PM108N, North House, 1 Devonshire Place
+ Register for this Event Print this Event Bookmark this Event

Description

International investment agreements (IIAs) are a significant manifestation of the impact of legal globalization on national public policy. These are thousands of (mostly) bilateral treaties through which states commit to protect the rights of foreign investors. Moreover, these obligations can be enforced by a system of binding international investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), which allows investors to file claims against host countries that allegedly violated their obligations under their IIAs. The legitimacy of IIAs and ISDS is highly contested, however. On the one hand, they encroach on states’ regulatory space (SRS) and delegate legal authority to ad-hoc arbitration bodies, which lack transparency and accountability. On the other hand, their alleged positive effect on foreign investment is uncertain. As a party to about forty IIAs, Israel’s SRS is certainly affected by IIAs. Such potential impact came to the fore when an American company, Noble Energy, indicated that it might turn to ISDS against the Israeli government in relations to a disputed gas exploration project. I examine the implications of IIAs and ISDS to SRS both globally and with respect to Israel. After elaborating on and illustrating these relationships in the global arena, I present a measure of SRS that facilitates a systematic comparison of IIAs across time and space on this key dimension. I show that, of late, states around the world conclude IIAs with greater regulatory space and that Israel tracks this global trend. An analysis of investment disputes in the energy sector suggests that Israeli IIAs expose the country to costly ISDS claims and potentially limit its ability to regulate in important policy areas.

Contact

Olga Kesarchuk
416-946-8938


Speakers

Yoram Haftel
Speaker
Professor, Department of International Relations, the Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Dan Breznitz
Chair
Co-Director of the Innovation Policy Lab, Munk Chair of Innovation Studies



If you are attending a Munk School event and require accommodation(s), please email the event contact listed above to make appropriate arrangements.

Disclaimer: Please note that events posted on this website are considered to be public events – unless otherwise stated – and you are choosing to enter a space where your image and/or voice may be captured as part of event proceedings that may be made public as part of a broadcast, webcast, or publication (online and in print). We make every effort to ensure your personal information is kept and used in compliance with the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA). If you have any questions please get in touch with our office at munkschool@utoronto.ca or 416-946-8900.



Newsletter Signup Sign up for the Munk School Newsletter

× Strict NO SPAM policy. We value your privacy, and will never share your contact info.