The IPL newsletter: Volume 24, Issue 497

December 15, 2023

News from the IPL

SHARE YOUR FEEDBACK FOR ISSUE 500

As the IPL Newsletter approaches its 500th issue, we invite you to submit a short email describing the value you derive from the publication. We will feature excerpts from this feedback in a 'From the IPL Newsletter Readership' section to celebrate the 500th issue. Whether you are a new subscriber or have followed the newsletter since Volume 1 in 2000, we could not have reached this milestone without your support. Please email  ipl.munkschool@utoronto.ca  and indicate whether you want your excerpt included anonymously or not.

NEWS

David Wolfe Discusses Canada's Innovation Challenges at Research Excellence Lecture

This article summarizes IPL Co-Director David Wolfe's recent lecture celebrating his selection as the recipient of the 2023 Desmond Morton Research Excellence Award. Professor Wolfe's lecture emphasized that governments need to coordinate innovation policy across all levels of jurisdiction and support the innovation capabilities of dynamic industrial clusters in diverse locations and economic sectors across the country. The lecture touched on three themes in particular: city-regions need to develop the organizational & institutional supports for collective action; initiatives need to be tailored to the circumstances of individual city-regions; and policy from upper levels of government must support local and regional development. Also see David Wolfe's recent interview with UTM News.

RESEARCH

Quantum Potential: The Expert Panel on the Responsible Adoption of Quantum Technologies

Council of Canadian Academies (CCA)
This new expert panel report from the Council of Canadian Academies (CCA) outlines a responsible approach to quantum-technology adoption. The report explores the commercialization potential of quantum technologies, articulates Canada’s position within the global quantum value chain, and examines those conditions and policy levers that might promote their responsible adoption. IPL Affiliated Faculty Member Darius Ornston served on the expert panel. IPL Affiliate Dan Munro served as a reviewer. IPL Co-Director David Wolfe supervised the review process.

Editor's Pick

DOE Launches New Office to Coordinate Critical and Emerging Technology

US Department of Energy
The United States Department of Energy (DoE) announced on December 12th the creation of the Office of Critical and Emerging Technologyto ensure U.S. investments in areas such as artificial intelligence (AI), biotechnology, quantum computing, and semiconductors leverage the Department’s wide range of assets and expertise. “Since their inception, DOE’s National Laboratories have been central to the nation’s scientific and technological advancement, and we are preparing to ensure that, as new technologies emerge, the United States leads the way in exploring those frontiers,” said U.S. Secretary of Energy Jennifer M. Granholm. “Our new Office of Critical and Emerging Technology will leverage DOE’s world-class scientists and technical capabilities in the interest of American security and competitiveness.”

Cities & Regions

Agency and the structural determinants of regional growth: towards a retheorisation

Helen Dinmore, Andrew Beer, Jacob Irving & Markku Sotarauta, Regional Studies
This paper addresses debates on the role of agency in shaping the economic future of regions. Scholarship on agency departs from the earlier focus of evolutionary economic geography, which highlighted the role of pre-existing structural conditions. This paper challenges the notion that agency is only found in intentional action and is limited to key actors within a region. It questions exclusive focus on the impact of entrepreneurial leaders, place leaders and government, and identifies agency in the accumulated micro-decisions of multiple decision-makers, using the example of workers affected by the closure of Australia’s passenger vehicle industry. In so doing, it underscores the twin roles of collective vision and meaningful implementation in the successful transformation of regions.

Statistics

Clean Investment Monitor: Q3 2023 Update

The Clean Investment Monitor (CIM)
This joint project of Rhodium Group and MIT’s Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research (CEEPR) tracks public and private investments in climate technologies in the United States. Investment in clean technologies is continuing at record levels in the United States, as demonstrated by new data from the third quarter of 2023. Actual clean energy and transportation investment in the US reached a record $64 billion in Q3 2023—an 8% increase from the previous quarter and a 42% increase relative to the same period last year. Clean investment accounted for 4.9% of total US private investment in structures, equipment, and durable consumer goods nationwide in Q3, up from 3.4% at the same time last year. Across the three investment segments—clean manufacturing, energy & industry production, and retail—clean manufacturing continued to post the most rapid growth, up 171% year-on-year to $14 billion in Q3. The electric vehicle supply chain continued to account for the majority of this investment.

The Hamilton Index, 2023: China Is Running Away With Strategic Industries

Robert D. Atkinson & Ian Tufts, ITIF
This report tracks various countries' shares of strategically important inductries. China now dominates the strategically important industries in ITIF’s Hamilton Index, producing more than any other nation in absolute terms and more than all but a few others in relative terms. Its gains are coming at the expense of the United States and other G7 and OECD economies, and time is running short for policymakers to mount an industrial comeback. As of 2020, China was the leading producer in seven of the ten strategically important industries in ITIF’s Hamilton Index. Overall, China was producing more than any other nation—and more than all other nations outside of the top 10 combined.

Innovation Policy

NY announces $1B for semiconductor R&D center; U.S. Department of Commerce awards $35M as first step in implementation phase of CHIPS and Science

Michele Hujber, SSTI
This SSTI post summarizes the Dec. 11th announcement that New York State was committing $1 billion to “a $10 billion partnership with leaders from the semiconductor industry such as IBM, Micron, Applied Materials, Tokyo Electron, and others to establish a next-generation semiconductor research and development center at NY CREATES’ Albany NanoTech Complex.” The post also summarizes the U.S. Department of Commerce's announcementthat the U.S. Department of Commerce and BAE Systems Electronic Systems, a business unit of BAE Systems, Inc., have signed a non-binding preliminary memorandum of terms (PMT) to provide approximately $35 million in federal incentives under the CHIPS and Science Act to support the modernization of the company’s Microelectronics Center in Nashua, New Hampshire.

Fasken
This post summarizes the proposed amendments to Bill C-27, the Artificial Intelligence and Data Act (AIDA). The amendments were submitted by Minister of Innovation, Science, and Industry François-Philippe Champagne to the House Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology on November 28.

Europe reaches a deal on the world’s first comprehensive AI rules

Kelvin Chan, Associated Press
This article summarizes recent developments in the European Union negotiations to clinch a deal on the world’s first comprehensive artificial intelligence rules, paving the way for legal oversight of AI technology. The AI Act was originally designed to mitigate the dangers from specific AI functions based on their level of risk, from low to unacceptable. But lawmakers pushed to expand it to foundation models, the advanced systems that underpin general purpose AI services like ChatGPT and Google’s Bard chatbot.

New Thinking in Industrial, Innovation & Technology Policy: Perspectives from Developed & Developing Countries

Columbia Center for Development Economics and Policy
After many years in the wilderness, industrial policy -- government interventions to stimulate innovation, accelerate technological change, and promote selected industries – is back on mainstream policy agendas in the U.S., Europe, and many developing countries. But even as the policy pendulum swings back toward government intervention, the knowledge base to guide industrial policy remains underdeveloped. This conference convened leading researchers from economics, sociology, engineering and other fields to take stock of what is known and what needs to be learned about the optimal design of interventions, the challenges in evaluating interventions empirically, and the difficulties that practitioners face on the ground. The presentations can be viewed here.

Policy Digest

Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada
The Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) is a financial Crown corporation wholly-owned by the Government of Canada that provides support to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and entrepreneurs. The Business Development Bank of Canada Act (BDC Act), which governs the BDC, requires that a review of the legislation be conducted on a regular basis. Covering the period from 2010 to 2022, Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED) led a review to evaluate the provisions and operations of the BDC Act, as well as examine how the mandate of the BDC has changed and could evolve to support the needs of SMEs across Canada over the coming decade.

Between December 2022 and March 2023, ISED convened 20 roundtable discussions (virtual and in-person across Canada) and received 45 written submissions.  Evidence-based research and analysis was conducted by ISED and other external researchers.

Performance Highlights included

  • increasing total assets significantly from $17.7 billion in 2010 to $41.6 billion in 2022

  • increasing the number of direct and indirect clients served from 29,000 to 95,000;

  • extending over $75 billion in loans and investments to entrepreneurs;

  • delivering close to 25,000 advisory mandates (which represent distinct advisory products or services provided to entrepreneurs at a specific point in time);

  • supporting the growth of the venture capital ecosystem, including by supporting Government of Canada programming; 

  • working with over 150 partners (as of 2022) to extend its reach to SMEs;

  • broadening its support to SMEs in underserved markets, including equity-deserving groups through targeted initiatives;

  • enhancing client service through the launch of its online financing platform; and,

  • delivering on key Government of Canada initiatives such as the provision of pandemic-relief to SMEs to address the COVID-19 pandemic, including the extension of approximately $7.8 billion through the Highly Affected Sectors Credit Availability Program (HASCAP), the Business Credit Availability Program (BCAP), and other measures.

The report included four forward-looking recommendations:

1. Strengthen accessibility and visibility: The BDC should increase the impact of its support for equity-deserving groups and underserved market segments such as newcomers, Indigenous entrepreneurs, and rural communities. The BDC should also enhance its offerings by expanding and clarifying eligibility requirements, and streamlining loan applications and other processes.

2. Improve reach across Canada: Recognizing that its activities are largely concentrated in the Quebec and Ontario regions, the BDC should strengthen its presence and engagement across Canada, particularly in the Prairie and Atlantic regions, through expanded partnerships and awareness-building initiatives to better support SMEs, including those in rural communities.

3. Reinforce collaboration and complementarity: The BDC should further improve its partnerships with stakeholders, including regional players. Further, enhanced cooperation with partners across the SME ecosystem is needed to ensure complementarity with private sector financial institutions, address market gaps for underserved market segments, and bolster alignment across Government of Canada initiatives.

4. Increase data cooperation and refine risk appetite: To continue to improve collaboration, transparency and accountability, the BDC should enhance its reporting and data-sharing practices with stakeholders and its shareholder. This should include the improvement of existing data collection and disclosure practices, in addition to the establishment of information-sharing arrangements with ecosystem partners. Further, the BDC should review its risk appetite to better support equity-deserving groups, undeserved regions and sectors, and newer businesses.

Events

EVENTS

GeoInno 2024

January 10th – 12th, 2024, The University of Manchester, UK
The Manchester Institute of Innovation Research at the Alliance Manchester Business School, University of Manchester, is organising the 7th Geography of Innovation Conference. The Geography of Innovation Conference provides a forum for discussion to scholars interested in scientific, policy and strategic issues concerning the spatial dimension of innovation activities. In line with the six previous editions of the conference, held in Saint Etienne (France) in 2012, Utrecht (Netherlands) in 2014, Toulouse (France) in 2016, in Barcelona (Spain) in 2018, in Stavanger (Norway) in 2020, and most recently in 2022 in Milan (Italy), the main objective of this event is to bring together some of the world’s leading scholars from a variety of disciplines ranging from economic geography and regional science, to economics and management science, sociology and network theory, and political and planning sciences. You can read more about the conference themes and scope on the Call for Papers page.

ISS2024

June 9-11, 2024, Gothenburg, Sweden
ISS2024 is the 20th biennial conference of The International Joseph A. Schumpeter Society. The conference takes place in Gothenburg, Sweden, between Sunday 9th June and Tuesday 11th June, 2024. The ISS2024 conference theme is "Transformation: Creative Accumulation and Creative Destruction in the Economy". The Deadline for submitting abstracts is Jan. 15th 2024.

2024 Industry Studies Association Annual Conference

June 13-15, 2024, Sacramento, CA, USA
This year's ISA conference is titled Empowering Community Wellbeing: Clean Energy, Sustainability and Industrial Strategy and will be held at California State University, Sacramento. In the heart of the world’s largest subnational economy, California, the Industry Studies Association proudly presents its annual conference with a theme that resonates with the future of our planet and communities. The conference will explore the dynamic interplay between California's pioneering efforts in clean energy and sustainability and their profound impacts on industrial strategy and community wellbeing around the world. Call for Paper and Panel Submissions

Subscriptions & Comments

Please forward this newsletter to anyone you think will find it of value. We look forward to collaborating with you on this initiative. If you would like to comment on, or contribute to, the content, subscribe or unsubscribe, please contact us at ipl.munkschool@utoronto.ca .

This newsletter is prepared by Travis Southin.
Project manager is David A. Wolfe